In today’s Washington Post, I write about the need for a debate devoted exclusively to foreign policy, and suggest some national security questions every candidate should have to answer before voters go to the polls. I asked a number of leading conservative national security thinkers what they would ask the candidates if given the chance. Here are some additional questions they suggested:
• Your views on balancing the budget are very clear. Yet the U.S. military faces an unprecedented challenge: 1) continuing current operations in the war against al Qaeda, 2) resetting a force suffering from a decade of constant combat, and 3) investing in systems that will help us deal with the growing power of China. Which of these are you willing to reduce or sacrifice to meet your fiscal goals?
• There is considerable discussion because of cuts to defense spending that we should “bring the troops home” from various overseas bases. Is that something you favor? If so, where would you draw down, and why? If not, why not?
• Since the end of the Cold War, the grand strategy of the United States has been in effect, to paraphrase President Bush’s words, to create a balance of power in the world that favors freedom. However, when the bipartisan review commission led by Stephen Hadley and William Perry examined the most recent Quadrennial Defense Review, they noted that this strategy was in jeopardy because, among other things, the military budget was inadequate for “recapitalizing” the services that had been living largely off the Reagan-era build up. If elected, would you either change American grand strategy to fit the defense budget? Or, would you reverse defense cuts in order to sustain that grand strategy?
• Most experts agree that the greatest limiting factor in strengthening American cyber defenses is a lack of clear policy guidance to employ the offensive capabilities we already possess. How would you create a national consensus on what we want, and will allow, the government to do in cyber space?
• How would you exercise civilian control over the military? When would you overrule a general?
• Under what conditions would you employ U.S. forces abroad?
• What is your view of the United Nations’ role in the world?
• How has President Obama failed our allies? Give three examples.
• What will you do to complete and preserve the victories in Iraq and Afghanistan? Is victory the proper objective in Afghanistan? If so, what would victory look like? And what is your vision for the residual (post-2014) American footprint in Afghanistan?
• What would you do about the two biggest dangers that remain in the greater Middle East: Pakistan and Iran, one already with nukes and the other on the verge?
• Should the United States have done more when the people of Iran rose up against their own government, only to be massacred in the streets? If so, what would you have done?
• Syria is massacring its own people. What would you do about Syria?
• How would you deal with countries in the Middle East that don’t share our values or form of government, but yet are partners in other areas?
• Is the Israeli-Palestinian dispute the central issue in the Middle East?
• Should it matter in our policies in the Middle East that Israel is a democracy?
• What is your position on extending FISA authorities for terrorist surveillance, which are due to expire?
• Will you commit to keeping in place the guidelines that make the FBI an intelligence-gathering agency, and not simply a law enforcement agency?
• What authority do you favor on intelligence gathering from, and interrogation and detention of, unlawful combatants?
• Russia today occupies parts of Georgia, and Russian democracy and civil liberties continue to move in the wrong direction. Do you agree or disagree with the premises of Obama’s “reset”? Can Russia be a real partner for the United States and how would you engage Moscow?
• What is your view of nation building? Should we do it, and if so, how can we do it better?
• Do you support continuing the U.S. embargo in Cuba, and what would you do to increase pressure for Democratic change in Havana?
• Mexico’s current president has waged a frontal war against drug traffickers that has sparked turf wars among the narco-traffickers costing 35,000 lives in the last five years. What can we do to reassure Mexicans so that they choose a new president next year who will keep up the anti-drug offensive?
• The United States has ceded its leadership in this hemisphere to Castro acolyte Hugo Chavez, who is an ally of Iran, Hezbollah, and narco-traffickers in our own neighborhood. As Fidel fades and Chavez struggles with cancer and reelection, how do we put freedom on the march and defend our security interests?