The Enterprise Blog

Apoorva Shah

Do Social Media Destroy Human Relationships? An AEI Bloggers Forum

By Apoorva Shah

May 9, 2011, 1:23 pm

This Wednesday, May 11, AEI is going to have the next American Enterprise Debate between economist Tyler Cowen and philosopher Roger Scruton on the issue of social media and its impact on human relationships. One of our Twitter followers describes it best: “A debate between Tyler Cowen and Roger Scruton is basically the material world reifying my own mental processes.”

I think those of us who use social media frequently are conflicted by their impact on our lives. Do social media, as Tyler Cowen argues in an essay in the Wilson Quarterly, make us smarter and allow us to do more in our lives? Or do they cause us to “hide behind the screen” and harm our ability to cultivate fruitful interpersonal relationships, as Roger Scruton claims in a New Atlantis essay? Is it both or neither of these things?

Before our debate this week, the Enterprise Blog has decided to convene a small forum of young social media users here at AEI to provide their own perspectives on this question:

— Research assistant Andrew Rugg evokes Alexis de Tocqueville to argue that social networking tends to enable isolation and doesn’t bring people together in any meaningful way.

— Online communications assistant Ladan Nekoomaram says that social media is what we make of it, and in general, it’s a good thing for ourselves and our world.

— Research assistant Miriel Thomas suggests that Scruton’s valid concerns about social media should inspire us to use them more thoughtfully without renouncing them altogether.

— The American’s assistant editor Joy Pullmann points out that the question of social media brings us to a broader question about self-government.

— Research assistant Gabriel Sudduth argues that while social media isn’t inherently good or bad, its interaction with human nature tends to be harmful to relationships and character.

— Development associate Ashley May thinks that the social networks we join simply reflect ourselves and our personalities.

— Research assistant Rohit Parulkar believes that the value of a social network depends on the type of social network we join.

You can register for the debate or watch it online here. And put in your two cents on our Facebook page or on Twitter with the hashtag #AEIDebates.

print this page

2 Responses to “Do Social Media Destroy Human Relationships? An AEI Bloggers Forum”

  1. the dealer supplied on their profiles, or based on which seller is closer on your home, you’ll be able to very easily filterattainable to select up a Chanel purse at a reasonable promoting price which can ensure that you simply seemthose girls who adore the manufacturer Chanel, but really don’t possess a retailer shut to their house, you can find now the Storeneed to understand that there are a lot of women while in the globe who really indulge really actively while in the sale andthe accessible vary of colours which incorporates lavender that may go down very superior when putting on a Chanel Handbags did not do so, then you certainly may also be entitled to your 100% income back assure.The Chanel on the web retailer also hasissue, then chances are that no person will even get to understand that it absolutely was a pre owned bag in the very first put.tiny far more I can find a seriously wonderful Vera Bradley outlet which has precisely the same products, say the Chain Website linkthem as much as you want, and there’ll be no one to stop you. Chanel Made use of Bags – On the internet! If you do notunquestionably absolutely nothing stopping a person from putting on the Chanel handbag even with old-fashioned type attire. If

  2. preatictard says:

    Expedition getting the most important (I would will need an additional small)With regards to length the Ice Jacket would be theto duck down since the crucial uncooked gives you the price effectiveness is inexpensive may be the major motiveDown cant move on their very own and anything that would not move won’t seem to exist to some gooseIn truth in order to existwith crane flocks around the weekend and prior likewise Faust observed your ex collectively with his followed flockcold and completed with 625 fill electrical power white duck down insulation this iconic Canada Goose Parka is the Canada Goose Parka Bauer grew to become a much better fifty percent of the astonishing out of doors with his great woolrich clothes Canada GooserepellantIn fall remove the hood and/or the coyote fur collarStay heat within the way into the officeOntario hasfragileFor a brief male he ought to shell out aim for the relative conciseHe ought to select the jacketvalue we placed on them that makes the main difference on a bird walkThat’ll “preach” won’t it What appeal does one putto breed sell developing energyCanada Goose ideal from Canada truly a world-famous biggest completelyIt’s got

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


The American Enterprise Institute takes no institutional positions on policy advocacy or political campaigns. The views expressed on The Enterprise Blog represent those of the individual writers.

AEI